| Year | President | Chairman | Year | President | Chairman | |
| 1924 | John Perry | John Perry | 1969 | Dr. Robert Merk | Ivor J. Lee | |
| 1925 | John Perry | Ray Neville | 1970 | Dominick Reale | Roy F. Buchman, Jr. | |
| 1926 | John Perry | Mott Robertson | 1971 | Michael C. Yourga | Charles H. Chance | |
| 1927 | Ray Neville | J. E. Perry | 1972 | Louis R. Epstein | George D. Myers | |
| 1928 | Mott Robertson | John P. Curry, Sr. | 1973 | Henry G. Evans | Louis Puskar | |
| 1929 | Hugh J. Garvey | Hugh J. Garvey | 1974 | Louis Puskar | Henry G. Evans | |
| 1930 | Myer Frank | Fred T. Fruit | 1975 | Louis Puskar | Henry G. Evans | |
| 1931 | Walter M. Dann | John Stevenson | 1976 | Roy F. Buchman, Jr. | James E. Feeney | |
| 1932 | Walter M. Dann | Ray Neville | 1977 | James E. Feeney | Nick Strimbu, Guy McCracken | |
| 1933 | Joseph H. Broscoe | Rev. W. Wishart, Mrs. W. Whitla | 1978 | James E. Feeney | Rich Schwab, Charles Graves | |
| 1934 | Fred T. Fruit | A. W. McDowell | 1979 | Anna Belle Jones | Robert P. Mayberry | |
| 1935 | E. O. Biggins | Leo H. McKay | 1980 | Anna Belle Jones | Irwin M. Yanowitz | |
| 1936 | F. J. Leuthner | S. H. Hadley | 1981 | Louis R. Epstein | Thomas R. Bohlender | |
| 1937 | Joseph T. Burke | S. H. Hadley | 1982 | Thomas Bohlender | James R. Topper | |
| 1938 | George Mahaney, Jr. | H. B. McDowell | 1983 | Thomas Bohlender | Thomas T. Demas | |
| 1939 | G. A. Harshman | H. V. Putnam | 1984 | Judith M. Achre | Henry G. Evans, Louis Epstein | |
| 1940 | H. V. Putnam | G. A. Harshman | 1985 | Judith M. Achre | Steve Gurgovits, Phil Marrie | |
| 1941 | H. V. Putnam | Leo H. McKay | 1986 | Harry R. Sheppard | Edward E. Schott | |
| 1942 | H. V. Putnam | L. R. Keough | 1987 | Harry R. Sheppard | Jim Sarvas | |
| 1943 | Leo H. McKay | Rev. W. Parsons, Ralph Johnston | 1988 | Paul G. Flint | George Warren, III | |
| 1944 | C. D. Kearns | J. H. Morrison, Ralph Johnston | 1989 | Paul G. Flint | Gregory Taylor | |
| 1945 | John K. Hodnette | Rev. James Murphy | 1990 | Edward E. Schott | James McCune | |
| 1946 | George S. Warren, Jr. | D. V. Sawhill, C. M. Musser | 1991 | Jim Sarvas | Robert Liptak | |
| 1947 | Dr. Allan Booth | George Warren, Jr., N. F. Vidal | 1992 | Jim Sarvas | Joseph George | |
| 1948 | Howard W. Boose | L. R. Keough, Ed J. Kavanagh | 1993 | Robert Liptak | James Cardamon | |
| 1949 | Burton Moss | James Frey, James Ingram | 1994 | Robert Liptak | Anthony Zucco | |
| 1950 | Edward J. Kavanagh | Donald Hittle | 1995 | George Warren, III | Donald Thomas | |
| 1951 | H. B. McDowell | Lynn Davenport | 1996 | Frank Evans | John Mastrian | |
| 1952 | Lynn Davenport | Nate Dunn | 1997 | Frank Evans | Francis X. Petrini, Sr. | |
| 1953 | Herbert E. Hetu | E. A. Owen | 1998 | Frederick A. George | Dominic Vadala | |
| 1954 | E. A. Owen | Austin J. Donoughe | 1999 | John K. Williams | Daniel E. Lawyer | |
| 1955 | Peter J. Joyce | Kenneth Bell | 2000 | John K. Williams | Vincent Cardamone | |
| 1956 | George S. Warren, Jr. | Henry Roemer, J. Grajciar | 2001 | Chester B. Scholl | Stephen J. Gurgovits | |
| 1957 | James Norman | John Chiles, Jr., James Norman | 2002 | Mark A. Longietti | James E. Feeney | |
| 1958 | Cyril T. Garvey | L. R. Keough | 2003 | William G. Perrine | Rex Knisley | |
| 1959 | Dr. Allan Booth | William C. Nicholson | 2004 | William G. Perrine | Gary Hinkson | |
| 1960 | Ray Eisenbies | Henry G. Evans | 2005 | Rex W. Knisley | Richard W. Epstein | |
| 1961 | Peter J. Joyce | Henry G. Evans | 2006 | Gary Hinkson | Kathryn and John Lima | |
| 1962 | William Nicholson | Burton J. Moss | 2007 | Richard W. Epstein | Ruthanne Beighley and Joseph George | |
| 1963 | Henry G. Evans | Michael C. Yourga | 2008 | Richard W. Epstein | Frank and Linda Evans | |
| 1964 | Mrs. Ed Finucane | H. B. McDowell | ||||
| 1965 | Louis Parker | Nick Strimbu, H. P. Forker | ||||
| 1966 | James Norman | Edward Frank, James Jones | ||||
| 1967 | Nick Strimbu | Richard G. English | ||||
| 1968 | Edward Frank | Louis R. Epstein |